Let’s get this out of the way right up front: I like living in Birmingham. I moved here from New Zealand with a job to return to, phoned them after 6 months and said “sorry – I’m not coming back”. That was nearly eight years ago.
But I am sick of this city competing for greatness.
Any time Birmingham has the opportunity to enter something in which we might emerge being considered ‘the best’, we’ll spend millions on our bid for selection. And guess what? Those other people we’re in competition with like their home town too. We pin so much on winning, and we fool ourselves into thinking that the outcome is anything other than arbitrary.
The empty rhetoric of ‘Birmingham is amazing’, ‘Birmingham is full of inspiring people’ and ‘Look how great Birmingham is’ is worse than unhelpful. It places us in a pointless competition with other places and centres our sense of self-worth around, on the one hand, what others think of us and, on the other, a series of vacuous mantras that if we repeat often enough, perhaps we’ll come to believe.
Meanwhile, our leaders are considered to be our champions and representatives to the outside world, rather than in charge of making things better. If there’s anything that Birmingham is the most amazing at, it’s putting faith in marketing as the solution to all things.
The website currently run by Jon Bounds (but up for sale) Birmingham It’s Not Shit focuses on the good things about our city – but also celebrates its ordinariness and quite often exposes its weaknesses in a way that demands that the people whose job it is to make things right actually do what is required of them.
The kind of empty-headed cheerleading that recently set the local Twittersphere abuzz for criticising the use of the words Birmingham and Shit in the same title are endemic. You will encounter it in every corner of public life in this city and it’s both saccharine and sickening.
“No – don’t say that! Birmingham’s awesome! Stay on message!”
Again – I like Birmingham a lot. I like the things that are great about it. I like the things that are ordinary about it. I am not, however, interested in whether it’s the best. Or even how good or bad it is as a city, judged on a range of different arbitrary metrics.
Birmingham is a perfectly good city. But let’s face it, other cities would have to decline right across the board on all sorts of fronts in order for it to be measurably better in any way.
We have, unarguably, our fair share of unpleasant, bureaucratic, miserable, selfish, obstacle-raising, incompetent, stupid, greedy, self-obsessed, ignorant and bad-tempered people in this city – just like pretty much anywhere else. We also have some incredibly lovely, talented, intelligent, giving, caring and dependable people – just like pretty much anywhere else.
And yet, we have adopted a PR approach to asserting Birmingham’s exceptionalism. It’s about employing superlatives, asserting dominance, comparing ourselves to others, focusing on the accomplishments of individuals and ignoring the actual day to day realities of living in Birmingham.
And the problem with a PR approach is that it directs people’s attention to the positive rather than addresses the negative. And it also directs time, money and resources in the same manner.
You want people to say that Birmingham’s amazing? Make it amazing.
You want it to be a safe city that’s easy to get around? Pedestrianise something. Give us light rail. Make it safe for cyclists.
You want it to be a healthy city? Do something about food in schools, encouraging local produce, organics, home gardening – all that stuff.
You want it to be a clean city? Do something about the litter epidemic and the widespread culture of just dropping shit on the ground.
You want it to be a nice place to live? Don’t just tell us about all the pretty – do something about all the ugly.
You want it to be a smart city? Support innovative educational initiatives that improve things for everyone.
You want it to be a fun city? Stop turning a blind eye to noise insulation regulation infringements when approving inner city housing construction while giving draconian noise abatement orders to live venues.
You want it to be an innovative city? Reward good ideas.
You want it to be a digital city? Install ubiquitous wifi and make public services that are ACTUALLY USABLE on the internet. Help people get online. Teach them how to make stuff and share it.
Want it to be a colourful and vibrant city? Legitimise and encourage street art and graffiti.
You want it to be a caring city? Address homelessness and poverty.
You want it to be a musical city? Focus on participation rather than popstars.
You want it to be a culturally exciting and artistic city? Find people who are already doing great stuff and support them to do more of it. Note – I didn’t say “champion them”. I said “support them”. That is to say – give them money to do more of what they do well, and then get out of the way.
They do not need an ad campaign so other people can be jealous of what we have.
Don’t say it can’t be done – because other places do all of these things successfully. But don’t just assert those things to be true, because even in those instances where they might be, it’s absurd to think that we achieved all we can. Saying “Birmingham is great” and doing nothing to make it so is like saying “I have no further ambition for Birmingham – it has achieved to its peak”.
I understand that there might not be the budget to do all the things I would like to have happen in this city. Things that would make it a better place than it is.
I also understand cultural tourism. I understand the need for promotional campaigns to bring people to the city and spend money on stuff. But the city is not reducible to a tourist attraction nor as a place to set up new businesses.
It’s already a place where a million people live. Getting people excited about what a handful of them have accomplished is not as important as making things better for the rest of them. Because the thing is – it’s just a city. This is the place where we find ourselves, and these are the people that we have ended up with. That’s community.
Living in Birmingham isn’t a prize that we’ve won, and regardless of how many cool and interesting people happen to live or come from here, there’s nothing exceptional about Birmingham that makes it better than other places – or some people better than other people.
The idea that “we’re better than them” is about as toxic a public sentiment as it’s possible to muster.
I don’t know whether or not we’re going to end up with an elected mayor. I’ll certainly be voting in favour of having one. But I don’t want our elected mayor to be Birmingham’s champion. We might as well just spend the money on a TV ad campaign.
Birmingham isn’t shit. But wouldn’t it be great if our city’s leaders decided to act as if it was, and that it was their responsibility to fix that?
Then you might see some amazing worth talking about.

Spot on. I couldn’t agree more.
41-and-a-bit-Brummie.
I totally agree with all of this. I’m a Brummie born and bred and all though I love my city and always shall, but I agree there are somethings that do need impoving and a lot to make it anything like London or another great city.
I was born a Brummie, but lived most of my adult life in other parts of Britain. Brum was amazing, once upon a time. When British cities were effectively city states, and Brum pioneered ‘gas & water socialism’ (under the Liberals). It quickly set up fine institutions and had no inferiority complex. But the 2nd half of the 20thC ended all that confidence. Don’t blame Brum for this. Blame the dominance of London & the SE. We’ve let the whole country become unbalanced, and Brum, like most other cities, has paid the price.
I’ve been saying this in various grumpy ways for years now, but never quite articulated as well as you’ve done here, so thanks.
Birmingham is a bit shit. That’s what makes it such a great place to live. It’s inability to be a Great City means you can do practically anything here if you want because everything’s accessible. And the broken, shonkey nature of a lot of the infrastructure means interesting things happen in the cracks. The worst thing that could happen to an area like Digbeth is for the Big City Plan to actually happen as it was intended.
But I digress. Arguing against the “Birmingham should pull it’s weight” idiots is hard because the assumption is if you don’t agree with them you hate Birmingham, which is nonsense. If I hated Birmingham I’d live somewhere else. What makes Birmingham a great place to live is the fact that is doesn’t do BIG very well. It does small excellently, though, spread thinly across a massive sprawl of communities. The best stuff I’ve seen in Birmingham has usually impacted 20-100 people at a time, but this never seems to count to the Big City morons.
But that doesn’t really matter. Those people will keep on doing the stuff that matters to them irregardless of what the shrieking baboons in the Brum-ist camp say and Birmingham will continue to be a great place to live in. Because it’s shit, not despite it.
Andrew, what the people who cause you consternation fail to grasp is that understatement is a core Brummie trait. The marketing of this city should take as its starting point the fact that most locals couldn’t give two shits what other people think.
This is just right, do too the comments after. It’s the very ordinariness that often makes this place, welcome as the improvements have been. Birmingham does get overhyped for awards it then doesn’t get, so perhaps we should concentrate on the smaller scale events and venues as Pete Ashton points out. There’s a lot of good stuff happening here but
Clueless. A bloke from New Zealand giving us his perspective? Urgh. I think to really appreciate this city you have to leave it and come back or move here and discovery it anew. Best place to live in the UK.
spot on Andrew. Moved to West Midlands from Australia (Melbourne), so all that stuff about marketing (versus doing something) rings true. Cities that sell themselves as “world-class” might as well take out ads saying ‘We’ve got a great big chip on our shoulder”. They don’t realise they are so much better than the cities they are comparing themselves to (eg Sydney, London) because they still have those human touches that make them liveable. Can’t wait to move to Birmingham and can’t wait for humans to realise that scars and wrinkles are so much more attractive than botox. Would rather live in a place where people talk to each other than cities where they either look down on people, suck up to them or think they are going to rob them.
To the negative ninnies alot is changing with birmingham you will be well aware, I’m here to tell you its going to be fine. The changes provided over the coming years are fantastic I. E central library next year, eastside park this year, big city plan. One final familiar point isthe grass is not greener on the otherside. Open your eyes to great things happening now and get involved, is Andrew making out he’s the only one who cares?
Brum is a bit shit. Thats always been the joke! In the eighties it was quite shit… we all knew it. It’s still a bit shit now… we’re just not allowed to say it anymore. But that’s alright. 1. We like it that way. 2. We can all be a shit sometimes too, it doesn’t make us less worthy human beings, and it doesn’t make Brum a less worthy city. We’ll leave the boasting and the big talk to our ‘leaders’ and get on with living our lives with a certain humility.
Great article.
Christ on a bike mate. Street art and graffiti? Nothing bleaker on earth. And how would you suppose a bunch of philistine councillors discern the ‘ugly’ and the ‘pretty’?
Fabulous refreshing sentiments. We don’t need to be the best- just better at what we already do.
Agreed that empty headed marketing guff has triumphed over the good things that do sometimes happen, but too often at the edges and not enough in the sprawling suburbs. Too big budgets live with too small minds. It’ll never work.
yes, birmingham IS shit. it’s ‘run’ by dullards. but, the people in birmingham are great. look at the big screen in town, yes the one that doesn’t fit inside it’s marble frame that purports to show the culture of the city. come away feeling none the wiser, then go to one of the festivals that is run in digbeth, there are many. impossible to come away without a unique experience, festivals that are run without council help…
You might not like it, and granted, maybe the city isn’t doing it well, but you can’t deny the power of PR. Just switch on the radio at 8am, or open a newspaper. Half the stories we receive as “news” are just regurgitated press releases written (or copied verbatim) from journalists with no time to do proper reporting. Birmingham does need to do all the things you mention, but much as it galls me to say so, it also needs to maintain it’s image in a PR dominated country, and stay on the agenda of the money-belts in London.
Birmingham’s not shit for fuck sake, go and live in somewhere like Milton Keynes, Hertford or Corby and then come back and say that. Just because we don’t go shouting from the rooftops about all the interesting stuff that is happening around the town doesn’t mean nothing is happening. We aren’t Manchester you know we don’t need to make ourselves heard.
Oh Lord, Birmingham, how I remember thee…. I only lived there cos my partner lived there…. now am back in Oz.. but still miss the place, walking back to Handsworth, down the dual carriage at midnight, DRUNK… walking from Smethwick to Moseley…. The Fox, Wolverhampton sighhhh