Panic on the streets of London
Panic on the streets of Birmingham
I wonder to myself
Could life ever be sane again?Panic – The Smiths (1986)
There’s a lot being said on the internet about last night’s escalation of riots in London and Birmingham (and spreading). So much so that blogging about it feels like repetition and empty rhetoric.
But there’s a lot of things that need saying, at least to clear my head about it, and so that I don’t get into arguments on Twitter. It’s a fantastic medium for all sorts of things, but it simply doesn’t have the space to accommodate the necessary complexity that reflection and analysis about events like these requires.
And I think that’s the observation I’d like to bring to this: there isn’t any simplicity here. No simple causes and certainly no simple solutions.
That smile isn’t happiness
People were looting and rioting. This doesn’t happen when people are happy with their lot. It just doesn’t.
And yet, people are reporting the gleeful grins of (very) young people kicking in shop windows and taking X-Box games. This was as much a party as it was scene of mass destruction. I saw it compared to A Clockwork Orange on more than one occasion.
How do you square those things?
Well, I imagine looting is exhilarating. I imagine when you have been force-fed the idea that human value comes from material possessions, then actually getting your hands on those possessions after being deprived any opportunity to earn those things for yourself – especially when surrounded by noise and shouting and fire and running – would feel like… well, not winning… but at least not like the misery, hopelessness and desperation that you’re used to.
It was already broken when they got here
The violence and the damage is inexcusable. The behaviour of the rioters is an affront to everything decent in society. It has ruined people’s livelihoods, caused massive damage to people’s lives and, most importantly, caused physical harm to innocent people.
It’s virtually unforgivable.
Likewise, the political and economic context within which this situation occurred is inexcusable. The people responsible for ensuring equity, a decent standard of living for all and – most importantly – opportunity and hope have not simply let us all down, they have done so willingly, knowingly, cynically and gleefully.
They have done it in collusion with those with the greatest wealth and power and it is nothing short of widespread criminality on a scale that eclipses anything done last night by any window-breaking yob. It is not about ideology, but about simple greed – for money, power and control, at the expense of the poorest, the weakest and the most disaffected in our communities.
This, by contrast, is utterly unforgivable.
Politics devoid of an ideal
No, the rioters were not “protesting”, and nor did they have a political agenda or a point to make – but that doesn’t mean that these events weren’t political.
It means precisely the opposite.
This is not an enactment of some set of political ideals – it is the result of them.
Crime and punishment
And no, the rioters are not the victims here. This is not some woolly liberal plea for the ‘sweet and tender hooligan’ (to keep the Smiths thing going). The law should and must be applied to all of last night’s transgressors. But the point is, it will. These children and teens will be caught, arrested and punished.
The same is not true for those who lost all the money, took massive bonuses, shut down all of the youth services and centres, and created a political climate that offers no hope and still – despite everything – only values and promotes conspicuous consumption.
But that position of extreme elite power seems utterly unassailable. The public response to the violent events of last night will simply be to swing predictably and depressingly further to the right. To demand tougher policing, rubber bullets, community segregation, stricter immigration laws, the reintroduction of the death penalty… and so on.
Hopelessness begets violence. Violence instils fear. Fear fosters deep conservatism.
Social media is to blame
At every available opportunity, the mainstream press is asking questions (or making assertions) about the role of social media – specifically Twitter and BBM – in the escalation and co-ordination of the violence.
Not only does this utterly vindicate the value of studying such media, it also shows a gross (and again wilful) misunderstanding of communication technology. Yes, criminals talk to each other. Who’d have thought?
My own Twitter timeline is filled with helpful people wanting to assist with the cleanup. Encouraging others to shop with local businesses to help them recover in this time of crisis. Offering assistance to rebuild whatever infrastructure has collapsed at the hands of this gleeful angry mob.
It’s heartwarming. People are, basically, wonderful. Technologies that allow them to express that simply amplify that fact.
But at the same time I can’t help thinking that this positive action they wish to engage in feels like cleaning up the work of one set of criminals, so that the other set of criminals can go back to business as usual. And I find that kind of distressing.
I’m not sure I want to engage in that particular conversation, because what I want to say doesn’t quite fit in 140 characters.
I don’t know what the answer is. Perhaps there isn’t one… at least, not one that can happen quickly. It’s complicated. Massively, frustratingly complex. This is the sort of thing that requires a fundamental change in our government, in our institutions, in our communities and in our people.
I do know that the answer isn’t more of the same – from either group of criminals.
But I also get the feeling that more communication, rather than less, is a good start.

Thanks for writing this. I wonder if the underlying problem (or cause), has something to do with our society’s concept of ‘progress’. We seem to collectively value technological and economic progress far more highly than ethical progress.
As a consequence our technology has developed beyond recognition over the last, say, 2000 years, whereas our ethics have remained stagnant. Some would even argue we’ve regressed. Ethics serves economics — there must be a latin dictum for that…
I agree wholeheartedly with all of what you have said here. Neither do I know what the answer is, or if there is one. It seems to me we need a Joseph Chamberlain for our times, but judging by the current political malaise, I fear it won’t be any time soon. Maybe things will get better before they get worse. We must hope for a better future and now we are painfully aware that the disaffected youth are prepared to bite, we must engage with them on a societal level. I’m not sure if half the population would even want to engage with them however, and if I’m brutally honest I might be amongst them. I want a quiet life. I’m sure a lot of the youth don’t want that either, because their lack of education from the start means they don’t want any now.
Do we write this generation off, and bring down the arm of the law? Do we offer them some other way, whatever that may be?
Is there education on both sides that needs to begin?
If society has shunned them and their parents for so long why would they want to join in with it, can and how do we all change?
Do we ghettoise them even further?
Open our gated communities?
Redistribute the wealth?
So many questions no-one wants to answer.
Nice article – I’m glad someone’s finally making the point that even thought the rioters don’t seem to be protesting a particular point, that doesn’t mean these riots aren’t political.
Our current government is exemplifying something that has existed for a while in society (and our previous governments) – that greed is good and a person is defined by their posessions. To me, looting when the opportunity presents itself is the natural outcome of that sentiment – and it’s a sentiment I despise wherever it occurs on the political/social/economic spectrum.
I’m a 12 yr ex-pat sitting in LA stunned by what I’m watching – but I guess I shouldn’t be – we use the same system here and it’s falling apart too:
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/youve-damaged-your-own-race-philly-mayor-blasts-teens-flash-mobs/
Sure – it’s presented through the fox news filter – I love that this is bullet ed:
“Take those God darn hoodies down, especially in the summer. Pull your pants up and buy a belt ’cause no one wants to see your underwear or the crack of your butt. Nobody.”
but there is now a curfew on Friday and Saturday night in Philadelphia!
And the predictable Fox listener response:
“I truly believe they need to lock them up and have their parents take some responsibility. Kids now are out of control they have no respect.”
…would reflect Andrew’s prediction for tighter controls….
The ever growing inequity between the haves and have nots would suggest that this is not an anomaly – but a beginning. Until the underlying causes are addressed, I think that things are going to get worse – everywhere. I don’t hear a politician on this side of the pond who is capable of changing the system – I’m guessing there isn’t a shining light over there either. So what happens?
Maybe we need to be thinking a decade earlier than Marr and Morrissey – I’m thinking Lydon’s lyrics might be more appropriate…