Select Page

One of the great things about academic conferences (the good ones, at any rate) is that there’s such a wealth and diversity of ideas bouncing around. It’s also one of the biggest problems of such things.

Usually, my work consists of exploring in depth an entirely narrow range of ideas in a relatively focused area.

Today, my brain has stretched in political and economic directions as well as in terms of media history and content.

I had never tried to debate economic theory with an economist, or political theory with a politician before today. I sprained brain muscles I didn’t know I had.

Depth is easy. Breadth takes work.

I’ve also had the most wide-ranging discussions about all sorts of things that I never would have expected to have conversations about – ranging from medieval British decor to the new incarnation of Battlestar Galactica. But y’know – that’s what happens when you stick a bunch of interesting people in the same room – and these are some interesting people.

And one of the drawbacks, of course, is that your own ignorance becomes readily apparent really quickly.

Take, for example, the gentleman I described just yesterday as ‘nice train man’.

Turns out he’s not only Sir Samuel Brittan, one of the more influential British economists of the late 20th century, but also the brother of Leon Brittan, the former Home Secretary. It turns out that I’m the only person in the UK not to have known that fairly vital piece of information – a key fact when attending a conference about an historic landmark document (that he co-authored) that restructured British broadcasting.

I still disagree with him on some fundamental levels, but I might have been less inclined to engage in debate on free market economic theory with quite as much enthusiasm had I known his credentials.

I mentioned yesterday that Sir Samuel tends to use the phrase ‘consumer sovereignty’ a lot. That’s his thing. That’s what he’s famous for. That’s his economic strategy. Taking issue with him over that is like having a chat with Darwin and saying you agree with him except for the bit about species adaptation.

I also have to try and equate in my head the fact that I so intuitively disagree with him, and yet I think he’s one of the good guys.

I might go back to calling him ‘nice train man’. Things were simpler then.

I’m probably fortunate that Sir Samuel, Sir Alan Peacock and the other members of the Peacock committee are long past trying to justify themselves to the likes of me, because it’s ended up making them quite indulgent, and I was able to spend entire mealtimes figuring out what they stood for, and what the key debates were.

Likewise, most of the media academics were willing to talk at length about the kinds of things they find interesting – which were not always the kinds of things you might expect.

There was also the visit to Powis Castle, which was quite spectacular. We wandered around the dimly lit and impossibly ornate halls looking, but not touching – and wondering out loud what the Designer Guys would have made of the completely over-the-top decoration.

“Do you think three chandeliers are too much with the tapestries, paintings and the tigerskin rug?”

“Oh, you bitch!”

But the sessions were, for the most part, quite hard work. I have eight pages of hastily scrawled notes that I fully intend to write up – though perhaps not tonight after all, despite all my good intentions when I headed up to my room.

The last seminar panel finished after 10pm and my head was swimming with British broadcasting history and politics as we finally made our way down to the bar, where the conversation turned to other matters of media importance: how good is the new Dr Who? Which was the best ever Buffy episode (I maintain it was ‘Hush’ but there’s a good case for ‘Once More With Feeling’)? What’s so great about Battlestar Galactica?

What I might try and do tomorrow on the train journey back home is summarise the conference in a single blog post, laying out the key positions and where the various people are in relation to that.

Or I might just keep it at the level of ‘It was nice. The sun was out. I saw a squirrel’. That’s the level I’m operating at just now – and unless I go and sleep immediately, that’s probably what I’ll be like all day tomorrow too.