As Karyn Hay rightly points out and as has been discussed at some length in the station’s defence, on a non-commercial Kiwi FM, even unsigned bands will finally get the airplay they deserve. Well, if you’re going around calling yourself ‘unsigned’ – then, yeah – you deserve what you get.
According to this NZPA Story, Kiwi FM is “a boutique station, which would become a forum for all New Zealand musicians, including those who were yet to find a record deal.”
If I was a member of the New Zealand music fraternity, I would probably take this as an insult. I think the time in which a record deal was the sole indicator of an artist’s worth as a commercially viable entity has well and truly come to an end.
In fact, the myth of the holy grail record deal has, in these days of online media, The Long Tail and independent music entrepreneurship, been well and truly burst.
The new music enterprise vs. the old model
I strongly believe that the most effective and sustainable model as a recording artist is now to form an independent company and operate as a small entrepreneurial organisation, bringing in expertise where needed, but essentially creating a self-driven career.
There are so many things the majors can be accused of, ranging from the dreadful PR gaffe of branding their customers ‘criminals’ (which, when you consider they are essentially marketing organisations, seems like a shocking inability to do their core job), to the withholding of royalty payments and preventing their artists from making a living, despite not wishing to release their material – as was famously the case with Aimee Mann.
But to my mind, the worst reason to get a record deal is in the area of recoupables. There is no other business I can think of that has the same theft-based model as the major record industry.
How it works
When you sign a record deal, you get an ‘advance’. This is an amount loaned to you by the label, which must be paid back out of your royalties before you start to earn on your released recording.
With the advance, you must pay for the recording of your album. Often, this must take place at a recording studio owned by the record company, and under the direction of a producer in their employ, that they appoint (to be paid for by you from the advance).
Then, to cut a long story short, there are three main types of royalties inherent in the recording.
1. The songwriter gets some for writing the songs (less the large percentage that goes to the publishing company – usually belonging to the record company)
2. The performers get some for playing the music (though in practice, this goes straight back to the record company to repay that advance)
3. The record company gets some for owning the recording (despite the fact that the performers paid for it through the recoupable advance)
But the reason this theft model is allowed to continue is largely through the stigma of the term ‘unsigned’, which carries all sorts of negative connotations of being substandard and unworthy of release.
For that reason, the broadcast of ‘unsigned bands’ is considered a public service and a huge favour to those bands. It’s a ‘leg-up’ to help them on their way to becoming proper, signed bands with real music careers.
Ban “unsigned”
I propose a banning of the word ‘unsigned’ and its replacement with the word ‘independent’ in all instances. The attribution of independence might instil the confidence in many bands to find ways to circumvent the traditional monetisation of recorded music – one that is built around the notion of exploitation of the artist – not just in an economic sense, but in a very real exploitative sense.
Rather than participate in the lottery of major label representation, in which a few artists become superstars, and the vast majority find themselves in permanent debt or shelved – more and more artists are taking the decision to turn down the record deal in favour of a more sustainable and modestly lucrative independent career.
The internet affords those who take the time to learn what you can do with it, the opportunity to be a self-determining entity, free to record and release, perform and collaborate, license and distribute your work as you see fit.
Deals with music industry professionals such as those found amongst the smaller, more friendly labels, management and promotion companies can still be done, but on the artist’s own terms.
The signed / failed dichotomy is dead. The record industry is still an enormous and lucrative business – but they’re far from the only game in town anymore. The environment has shifted to accommodate the independent artist in a far more sustainable and profitable manner.
Radio airplay is not the only way to get heard – and traditional record company publicity is far from the only way to find an audience. I’m not saying there aren’t any gates and gatekeepers – they’re still all there. It’s just that there are no longer any fences.
The disabling power of language
Now, this is essentially a case of the power of words to define attitudes. We don’t call people who use wheelchairs ‘cripples’ anymore, and nor do we use the terms ‘nigger’ or ‘boonga’. So let’s drop the ugly and disabling language of ‘unsigned’ bands, yeah?
Language has the power to shape perception. If an audience is introduced to a piece of music as that of an ‘unsigned band’, then this has a direct effect on the way in which that music is received. Worse, a band considering themselves having failed to achieve ‘signability’ will often simply give up their chosen career.
Independent artists – at least the ones I’ve met – are motivated, busy and resourceful people, making a living by creating value for others and doing what they love. It comes down to the words we choose.
But – let’s be clear about this – this is not about being ‘politically correct’ – rather, it’s about descriptive accuracy. So, while we’re at it, it also seems appropriate to replace the word ‘signed’ with ‘indentured‘.
Seems a better fit.

bravo Andrew! You can blame it all on David Geffen and the bloody Eagles too…artist recoupment only became an issue as a result of their antics in the seventies, but, boy, when the record companies bought into it, they really bought into it and the damn thing is structured (with packaging deductions/ TV advertising rates / new technology deductions and a multitude of other ways to cut the amount credited to the recoupment)so that most acts NEVER recoup