Select Page

This weekend, my year 2 radio students are finishing off an essay about the impact of changes to the New Zealand radio industry since 1990. Their essay can focus on either political economy, audiences and content, or technology.

They’ve been given a truckload of information over the semester from some great guest lecturers but it’s a bit like going to a great smorgasbord. You can’t possibly fit everything on your plate. Instead, they’ve been sent to get the academic equivalent of a seafood platter, and can select from the vast array of material at their disposal, and arrange the tidbits that will make it all make sense as a written ‘dish’ (Would you like another mix with your metaphor, sir?).

A few of them have sent me questions via email, which I’ve attempted to answer as hepfully as I can, while remaining cryptic enough for them to be required to do their own thinking (which, after all, is the point of the exercise).

Student A writes:

In my technology notes I have written for some reason that after deregulation the large number of stations ‘had to divide up equipment and dollars’.

Did they?? advertising dollars would have been divided up, but not money for technical stuff..?

Surely separate stations wouldn’t share equipment unless they were in the same building..?

Did this mean there was less equipment per station?

Also… In Alan Cocker’s work, he keeps alluding to the fact that broadcasting policy (dereg) caused some technologies to emerge. He never actually says that though.

But in the marking schedule it also says ‘…understand broadcasting policy and EMERGENT technologies.’

I just don’t understand how deregulation could CAUSE anything technical in the world of technology to develop. I thought technology developed independent of politics..?

Do you think this is not talking about technical stuff at all but rather just processes like Matthew Reid’s system? If so, couldn’t this development have occurred even if radio was still regulated..?

My response: You’ve pretty much answered your own question… and you’re absolutely right. Competing radio stations didn’t share equipment.

After deregulation, stations that hadn’t existed before set up with new, second-hand or borrowed equipment – but they didn’t walk into the offices of the pre-existing stations and say “I’m here for half of that, please…”

You’re also right that deregulation didn’t cause digital technology. However, there may be certain technologies that arose out of a demand created in an environment caused by deregulation.

Matthew Reid, for instance, might not have come up with a way to synchronously play back different ads in different regions if you weren’t allowed to have the same station playing the same content in different regions. Radio stations only wanted him to build in that feature of Airwaves because it was something that they wanted (and were allowed) to do.

Technology doesn’t develop independently of politics, but neither is it caused by politics. Like most such things, it’s a much more complex relationship than either of those views would have it. I think it’s fair to say technological progress informs – and is informed by – political process.

Student B’s question:

I was wondering if it’s all right to mention dates ie. 1930’s and 1950’s etc when discussing how things used to be in radio? Because the Q. says since the 1990’s – but as i’m doing content and audiences all the significant changes happened before then. And secondly, at the beginning of my essay, I discuss how deregulation has impacted radio… even though that happened in 1989 – is this ok to mention?

My response: It’s fine to mention dates. Any historical discussion needs context, so it’s good to quickly mention the events that led to your starting point – especially if you’ve identified a common thread that is being continued.

That said, making comparisons to the 1930s is less useful than making comparisons between post-1990 developments, and pre-1990. Situate that within an historical narrative, and there’ll be cause to draw on earlier stuff, but saying that things are different now to how they were 80 years ago is less informative.

Deregulation is unavoidable. While it was written into legislation in 1989, the effect came gradually. It wasn’t like an on/off switch: first regulation then no regulation. Change happens over time – and arguably, change as a direct result of deregulation is still going on today.

Student C:

I’m taking the technology focus on the essay and I was wondering apart from things like networking, automation, home radio and digital radio are there any other key advances that are essential to the essay? Im also looking into the way frequencies no longer need to be so far apart?

My reply: First, I’d say that no one specific area is essential to the essay. You need to talk about the impact of technological change – not just the changes themselves.

That said, there are really four main areas in which technology has changed: administrative, production, transmission and context. That is, the way radio is run as a business, the way programmes are made, the way they are sent to (and received by) listeners, and the general technological context that radio is situated in as far as society goes. Think along those lines, and you’ll get an idea of the kinds of changes you need to be thinking about in order to figure out what the impact has been.

Hope that’s more helpful than it looks.