Select Page

A few interesting thoughts flying around at the moment. I read a book last night by Gary Genosko – ‘McLuhan and Baudrillard: The Masters of Implosion’ (1999, Routledge, London), and I started (second time round) this morning on Donald Theall’s ‘The Virtual McLuhan’ (2001, McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal).

One of the concepts I always had most difficulty with when dealing with McLuhan – and it’s one that pops up in both of these books – was his idea that the electric light bulb is pure information – a medium without a message. While I agree that the electric lightbulb ‘illuminates’ the recipient, I had trouble making the connection between the bulb and information. Of course, now that the purpose of my enquiry is to discover whether, as I suspect, digital technologies shape our consciousness in certain ways (the advent of Digital Man), the metaphor of the lightbulb is entirely appropriate.

Given that a lightbulb is ‘pure’ information, it is necessarily digital data. Binary. On or Off. In fact, it is a form (in the Platonic sense) of the core atomic element of all information in the digital realm – zeroes and ones. The lightbulb is, essentially, an info-archetype.

As zero represents off and one is on, all data can now be represented by lightbulbs (a hell of a lot of lightbulbs, but lightbulbs nonetheless). There is no transition between one state and another. Perhaps this leads to the idea that quantum physics is necessarily a model of digital thought. I’ll try and explain how I got there.

Quantum physics is a branch of science that has been around for almost a hundred years in its full form, but is yet to take hold of the public consciousness in the same way that Newtonian physics did. Perhaps communication theory in the shadow of McLuhan (and his lightbulb) can shed some light on the reasons why (to dreadfully mess with my metaphor).

In Newtonian physics, you have cause and effect. Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. For something to move from one place to another, energy must be exerted, the object moves in space, travels at a certain velocity and can be pinpointed at any given moment as being headed in a certain direction, occupying a certain space that exists between departure and destination points, and being part of a continuous flow. There is no sequence of positions, there is movement.

In Quantum physics, which deals largely with the odd behaviour of sub-atomic particles, certain mind-bending events can be seen to occur. For a start, an electron, travelling in a pre-set path around the nucleus of an atom, can be acted upon so that the electron jumps from one orbit to another. If so acted-upon, the electron stops following the path it’s on, and starts on another orbit – either closer to, or further away from the nucleus. However, at no point does it move between the two orbits. It is first in one point in space, then in another – without travelling in between. Heisenberg, who had the unenviable task of trying to explain some of this stuff to the general populace, also had to admit that when viewing sub-atomic particles, you could never identify both the direction of travel and position in space. As soon as you know where something’s going, and how fast it’s travelling, you no longer have any idea where it is. If you find out where it is, you cannot possibly know where it’s off to.

Then there’s that tricky effect whereby our bulb emits light, which exists as both particles and waves – and seems to change its mind as to which it really is depending on what experiment you’re conducting to prove one way or the other.

So here’s the thing. It comes back down to predominant modes of thought, and these are shaped by our technologies. To a literate culture, Newton is a sensible man whose theories are linear, logical and essentially demonstrable. Einstein is a genius, but essentially untenable because of the can of worms he opened by messing around with spacetime, and opening the door to the likes of Schroedinger, who apparently doesn’t treat his pets well.

However, with the advent of digital technology, the predominant mode of thought is somewhat different. CDs and hard drives are random-access devices, not rooted in any kind of linear progression. Hypertext enables travelling without moving. The use of email and webchat enables co-presence without that tedious messing around with physical space. This is the kind of sociological, technological and psychological environment in which quantum theory can be finally embraced as a fair and reasonable representation of how the world works.

As far as how this affects media generally – and thereby the minds of those who use digital media, consider the following example: music can be recorded and distributed digitally. As such, it can be accurately represented by lightbulbs – in fact, 16 lightbulbs turned on and off every 44,100th of a second (a CD uses a 16-bit word with a sample rate of 44.1kHz). Imagining such a thing, we arrive at a place where music – which, as sound, is fundamentally an analogue phenomenon – is expressed in its ‘pure information form’ as both particles and waves. A dual (or binary) existence.

For the purposes of this exercise, let’s accept for the moment the idea that all experience is mediated. We don’t see objects, we see the light reflected from them. We don’t hear musical instruments, we hear the disturbances in the air that they create. That sort of idea. As all experience is mediated, and the electric bulb is the archetype of all information, one could argue that the essential nature of the universe is binary and that digital life is thereby necessarily ‘real life’. Patently untrue, but a fun destination to arrive at.

Listening to Marc Ribot’s ‘Saints’ album (Atlantic). Music should be ‘played’ in all senses of the word ‘play’ – and Ribot does this brilliantly.